Opportunities and challenges in value chain analysis for sustainable management of sharks and rays

Leurs, Guido and Walsh, Matthew Bjerregaard and Haque, Alifa Bintha and Collins, Claire and Glaus, Kerstin and Kizhakudan, Shoba Joe and Muktha, M and Muttaqin, Efin and Simeon, Benaya and Tovar-Ávila, Javier and Govers, Laura L and Walker, Paddy A and Friedman, Kim J (2024) Opportunities and challenges in value chain analysis for sustainable management of sharks and rays. Marine Policy, 163. pp. 1-11. ISSN 1872-9460

Text Marine Policy_2024_Sobha Joe Kizhakudan.pdf Download (5MB)

Abstract

Studies on elasmobranch trade have often focused on a single commodity, shark fins. Such a narrow focus can result in an incomplete understanding of the socio-cultural importance of sharks, limiting discussion on the range and efficacy of potential management interventions. Assessments must be performed across the value chain from fisher to retail vendor to better conserve vulnerable elasmobranch species, offering a broader view of capture, use, and trade. Here, we collate insights from shark value chain assessments conducted in eight countries (Mexico, Peru, Guinea-Bissau, India, Bangladesh, Sri Lanka, Indonesia and Fiji) spanning five continents. Approaches and processes implemented in a shark value chain analysis (VCA) were reviewed to: (1) understand better approaches and tools and (2) collate shared experiences. Our results demonstrate that VCAs broaden the outlook of fishery and trade assessments when capturing a more comprehensive range of economic and socio-cultural aspects (e.g., livelihoods, cultural use of commodities) of trade in all shark commodities. Time invested in various components of assessments produced different outcomes, with considerable returns from stakeholder selection, survey design, and assessor/stakeholder relationship building. Contrastingly, results demonstrated that efforts in communication with stakeholder groups and policymakers could be further streamlined to focus on key results using a variety of communication formats. Outcomes from this study offer guidance to those embarking on shark VCAs, facilitating improving the assessment process and outcomes.

Item Type:	Article
Uncontrolled Keywords:	Value chain analysis; Socio-ecology; Trade; Elasmobranchs; Shark; Fisheries; Food security; Resource management
Subjects:	Demersal Fisheries > Shark fisheries Elasmobranch Fisheries Fish and Fisheries > Fisheries management Food Chemistry
Divisions:	CMFRI-Kochi > Marine Capture > Finfish Fisheries Division Subject Area > CMFRI > CMFRI-Kochi > Marine Capture > Finfish Fisheries Division CMFRI-Kochi > Marine Capture > Finfish Fisheries Division Subject Area > CMFRI-Kochi > Marine Capture > Finfish Fisheries Division
Depositing User:	Arun Surendran
Date Deposited:	02 Apr 2024 04:43
Last Modified:	02 Apr 2024 04:43
URI:	http://eprints.cmfri.org.in/id/eprint/18257

Actions (login required)

View Item